Skip to content

Struggle using hercules for public repo #70

Open
@DavHau

Description

The dream2nix repo was migrated to using hercules, but we have a problem where PRs of external contributor are blocked by the hercules jobs not executing.

Github does have a feature to require maintainer confirmation before CI runs on PRs of first time contributors, but this gets ignored by hercules. Even when confirming, the jobs won't run.

I heard a recommendation to use merge queues, but I don't see this as a viable alternative. Running status checks should be a cheap operation that doesn't require much human intervention. Queuing a PR for merge requires the review to be finished thereby making running status checks an expensive operation.
This seems to go against some principle of continuous integration which is to get quick feedback on the quality of a change.
Practically speaking, if I see that a PR fails some tests, I might decide to spend my time instead reviewing higher quality PRs, but I cannot do that if can't easily get a CI status.

Is there a simple way to fix it which I'm missing?
Does hercules plan anytime soon to integrate with github's feature that allows maintainers to confirm CI runs for external contributors?

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions