Cedar support?

[haskelash]

I'm trying to get our project to work with Travis CI which uses xctool. Our project uses Cedar as a testing framework. On Travis, our project builds fine and everything is green, but it doesn't actually run the tests. It says "** TEST SUCCEEDED: 0 passed, 0 failed, 0 errored, 0 total **"

I also get this warning

skipping: This test bundle contained no tests.

Is there a way to get Cedar working with xctool/Travis?

Thanks.

[LegNeato]

Hmmm, the Cedar team's travis build seems to use the stock (xctool) build and test. We don't use it at FB though so can't confirm for sure.

[LegNeato]

The logic for that is here:

https://github.com/facebook/xctool/blob/master/xctool/xctool/RunTestsAction.m#L559

Perhaps we are keying off something that doesn't hold with Cedar? Mind reproing and debugging a bit?

[ExtremeMan]

Most likely these lines don't support other testing frameworks: https://github.com/facebook/xctool/blob/master/otest-query/OtestQuery/OtestQuery.m and https://github.com/facebook/xctool/blob/master/Common/DuplicateTestNameFix.m.

[jonstorer]

Any movement on this? I'd love to use xctool on travis, but without Cedar support, it's impossible.

[ExtremeMan]

We will be happy to review PR. Though I don't think we will add it by our own in the nearest future.

Thank you for reporting this issue and appreciate your patience. We've notified the core team for an update on this issue. We're looking for a response within the next 30 days or the issue may be closed.

[adamhrz]

@haskelash There is a new version of Cedar that works on XCode 7. We were seeing the 0 tests and turned out to be Cedar and PivotalCoreKit which were both updated September 16th cedarbdd/cedar#354

[ExtremeMan]

@adamhrz, ah, awesome. Could you just double confirm that xctool + Xcode 7 + Cedar are working together? If yes, I will close the issue then.

[adamhrz]

@ExtremeMan Just digging out my command line xctool command for this project and will confirm

[ExtremeMan]

@adamhrz, thanks a lot. I appreciate that.

[adamhrz]

@ExtremeMan @haskelash confirmed xctool 0.2.4 running xcode7cedar tests fails but xctool 0.2.6 running xcode7cedar tests pass

[ExtremeMan]

Awesome, @adamhrz. Thanks a lot for looking and confirming! Closing since it is fixed.